The Electronic Bulldog - May 31, 1995

©1995 Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Telecommunication


Stories for May 31, 1995

Contents


Dealing with death

They can't cure, but hospice volunteers offer comfort and relief from pain

(Click here for full photo and caption.)
 * By Dawn J. Wagner *
	
	Like two schoolgirls, Patricia Wieczorek and 
Rose "Bubba"Finklestein lifted out each glittering 
piece of jewelry from the shoebox, giggling as they 
tried on earrings and necklaces.
	Wieczorek paraded around the small bedroom, 
swaying her hips and pretending she was walking 
the runway. Finklestein laughed loudly.
	"We get together and talk and laugh," said 
Finklestein, a 96-year-old spitfire.
	"Sometimes we watch those nasty TV shows 
about sex change operations,"added Wieczorek, a 45-
year-old housewife.
	"That's what I'm going to do,"Finklestein said, 
giggling.
	"Get a sex change?"Wieczorek asked as the two 
broke up into another fit of girlish laughter.
	The two carry on like they have known each 
other for a lifetime. Each week they exchange 
memories and stories of their children. And they 
laugh a lot.
	It was only January 1994 when the two met. 
That was when Finklestein was told she had less than 
six months to live, and when she was assigned to 
Wieczorek as a hospice patient.	
	Finklestein is dying from colon cancer. She is a 
patient at Community Hospice, one of the 12 centers 
in the Valley designed to provide pain relief care for 
people with terminal illnesses.
	To be admitted to any of the Valley hospice 
programs, a patient must have an incurable disease 
that has reached its advanced stages. The diagnosis 
must be confirmed by two independent doctors 
before a patient is considered for the program.
	 Most stays in hospice are covered through 
Medicare.
	"When a patient goes on hospice, they are no 
longer looking for a cure,"said Nancy Foster, 
volunteer coordinator for Community Hospice. "They 
are looking for pain relief and comfort care, and we 
do everything we can to make them comfortable."
	One "comfort"service offered by hospice is a 
one-on-one volunteer who serves as support for 
family and patient.
	Wieczorek has volunteered for more than two 
years.
	 It is not a volunteer program for everyone. 
Foster said the people who serve as volunteers 
willingly deal with death on a day-to-day basis.
	 "These are not the Girl Scout cookie bakers or 
the hospital candy stripers,"she said. "They are 
people who are willing to do something that most 
people think is very strange."

Witnesses to death
	The volunteers take care of everything from 
afternoon visits to making funeral arrangements to 
family bereavement. In many cases they have 
witnessed the death of a terminally ill family 
member.
	James McCready, a full-time funeral director 
and part-time volunteer at Hospice of the Valley, 
became involved after his mother died.
	"My mother had cancer and she was with 
hospice,"McCready said. "I got involved with Hospice 
of the Valley because I felt like I wanted to give 
something back."
	LeeAnn Hudson, a volunteer in training, said, "I 
was living with (my aunt) and the whole time she 
was dying we never talked about it. I think being a 
volunteer will make it easier for me to talk about it."
	Approximately 85 percent of all volunteers 
have had previous experience with hospice, Foster 
said. "Payback is a big part of it,"she said. "I think 
that's what the program really is; people want to 
become a part of it afterwards. They take the 
experiences from their family to make it easier on 
another family."
	The rest of the volunteers feel the need to help 
others in times of heartache.
	"I was watching a television program and I saw 
people talking about it and I thought it was 
interesting,"Wieczorek said. "It's a point that 
everyone, including the family, has to go through and 
if I could help make the transition from life to death 
easier, I thought it would be a big help."
	All potential hospice volunteers must complete 
a rigorous training program designed to familiarize 
them with the hospice system, goals and procedures.
	Spirituality, stress management, organ 
donation, bereavement and the physical aspects of 
dying are covered in the 10-week training course.
	At weekly sessions, the "group"listens to 
qualified speakers explain death and the grieving 
process in every way imaginable. A trip to the 
mortuary to learn about embalming and funeral 
arrangements is one of the most talked about 
sessions.
	"This place spooks me,"Hudson whispered, as 
she and the other four group members walked 
through Camelback Sunset Chapel and peered at 
caskets and cremation containers. "I've never been to 
a funeral. I've never been to a viewing and I've 
never seen anybody in a casket, so it's all a little 
hard for me to understand."
	After giving the tour, the funeral director, 
McCready, said, "I've been able to work with hospice 
volunteers on a different level. When I trained to be 
a hospice volunteer, I went through a mortuary tour 
and I was kind of disappointed. I thought if I could 
ever do this class for volunteers, I would like to try 
to make it better and more thorough."
	Even though all five trainees were impressed 
by the tour, each said she was nervous about her 
first patient.

The first family is tough
	Even though volunteer Sharon Haas has 
recently dealt extensively with the grieving process, 
she remains worried about comforting her first 
family.
	"I recently buried all the members of my 
family so I have a lot of experience with this,"she 
said. "It's always traumatic no matter how much you 
expect it. You just have to be as supportive as you 
can to help them through it. But I'm sure I will be 
crying right along with the family, so it will be hard."
	Catherine Addiego, another volunteer, said her 
motivation comes from previous hospice experience 
coupled with the training.
	"You start off loving people and then you think 
when is the hardest time emotionally for those 
people, and it's always at the time of death,"Addiego 
said. "I think it's going to be hard but it will be worth 
it.
	"It's important to have these classes so that you 
learn what kind of things to say and what not to say. 
I'm just hoping I'm as good as some of the people 
were with my mother, who was in hospice."
	By the end of 10 weeks, most volunteers have 
undergone a "human growth experience,"Foster said. 
Before most volunteers have dealt with their first 
patient, they have  learned to analyze their own 
feelings about death and dying.
	"I'm not sure it's physically visible,"Foster said. 
"Some people come a long way. There are some who 
are really uncomfortable in the beginning and then 
have resolved a lot of personal issues for themselves 
by the end of the training."
	Wieczorek said her outlook on life was re-
evaluated after completing the training.
	"It makes you realize that no matter how rich 
or how poor you are, everybody goes through the 
same things,"she said. "You know the (emotional) 
steps people go through and the physical steps they 
go through, so you know when the end is coming 
near. It takes the scariness out of it."
	But it still doesn't stop the hurt.
	Helen Ziffer, who has been volunteering for 
more than five years at the Community Hospice at St. 
Luke's Medical Center in Phoenix, said it still breaks 
her heart every time she loses a patient.
	She remembered one man who was dying from 
pneumocystis pneumonia, an AIDS-related illness.
	"His name was Mike,"she said, sadly. "He was 
dying and I went to go visit him in the hospital. He 
asked me, 'Why are you in here? I have a contagious 
disease. Nobody will come in here besides my doctor.' 
I told him I was going to stay with him."
	Ziffer said she talked with the young man often 
and quickly built a friendship.
	"One day he asked me to call his family in 
California,"the 79-year-old nurse said. "I called them 
and they told me they wouldn't come out to see him. 
I was so upset. I couldn't tell him that, so I went 
back and told him I couldn't reach them.
	"I went back a little while later, and he asked 
me if I would pray with him because he hadn't 
prayed in years. I held his hand. He was a big 
man."Her blue eyes filled with tears. "I just held him 
and I prayed. . . and he died."
 	Ziffer, who is the team leader at the Community 
Hospice, heads up a group of volunteers who choose 
to visit all the patients in the center, rather than 
visiting on a one-on-one basis.
	Wieczorek, who now devotes her time to 
individual care, began hospice work at the center. 
	"I really enjoyed going to visit the people in the 
hospice center because I never had one person and I 
could go from room to room,"she said. "A lot of 
people died between visits so you never really got 
close to anyone.
	"It was nice to be able to comfort them and to 
hold their hand and just talk with them about their 
life. A lot of people wanted to talk about it and you 
were kind of a catalyst because you got to do that."
	She described a cheerful man in his 80s who 
was dying from prostate cancer.
	"I walked in there and we started talking and 
we had all this stuff in common,"Wieczorek said. "He 
grew up in Buffalo and so did I. We both knew the 
same streets. I sat there for over an hour with him 
talking and laughing."
	During the visit, the man told Wieczorek his life 
history and each exchanged stories and memories. 
	"The next week I came in and he was kind of in 
and out of it,"Wieczorek said. "I talked to him and 
held his hand and then I went in the next week and 
he was in a coma.
	"So I sat next to him and I held his hand and 
rubbed his face and I repeated to him everything he 
had told me. I told him that I remembered him 
telling me about his wife and I went on about his 
honeymoon and I said, 'I don't know if you can hear 
me, but I enjoyed talking to with you. Your wife is 
going to see you soon.' 
	"Then he squeezed my hand. I don't know if 
heard me or not, but it was nice to be able to do that 
for him. He died that night."

Death brings freedom from pain
	For patients who suffer from afflictions such as 
cancer, the pain can be extremely strong, even with 
carefully monitored medication. The hospice system 
provides strong pain relief, tailoring each dose to the 
specific needs of the patient. 
	Morphine and other pain relievers are 
prescribed extensively by registered nurses.
	"I look at it as such a blessing for a person who 
has cancer and is dying and suffering,"Ziffer said, a 
smile spreading across her face. "You see them 
suffering so much and it's so important to realize that 
the person will soon be out of their suffering and it's 
going to be OK.
	"Otherwise I couldn't go on doing this. I believe 
they are going to God and they are meeting their 
families and that they are going to be happy without 
any suffering."
	Solid spiritual beliefs and a strong sense of 
self-like are common traits found within the group of 
hospice volunteers. Most talk vividly about heaven, 
God and the end of physical suffering. Their 
spirituality allows them to become attached to their 
patient and family, Ziffer said.
	Although only loose bonds generally develop in 
the care center, a one-on-one experience moves to an 
entirely different level, Wieczorek said.
	"I would go see Bubba every week and we just 
grew closer and closer,"she said. "After a couple of 
months, her daughter got sick and died within one 
week. I remember she called me and told me that 
(her daughter) had died. When I came to see her, she 
told me that I was the only one she had, and she 
didn't know what she would do without me.
	"I realized that I was the only one there for 
her."
	A sometimes unavoidable loss of family 
support is something the volunteers must deal with 
often. Ziffer said she often becomes the patient's 
primary companion when she volunteers on an 
individual basis.
	One patient, Dennis, who was dying from cancer 
of the esophagus and could only communicate by 
blinking his eyes, "had nobody,"Ziffer said, her hands 
trembling. "His daughter-in-law wasn't able to help 
because she had her own children, so he was alone 
unless I was there. I couldn't believe how wonderful 
he was. He took so much pain and it was so sad, but 
I'll never forget how he took it all and still smiled.
	"Here he was dying and there was no one 
around but me, practically a stranger."
	Ziffer visited and comforted the lonely man for 
four weeks until the end, when just the two were 
together.
	She said: "I took his hand and I held it and I 
said to him, 'Would you like to pray with me?' and he 
blinked his eyes to tell me yes. So I held his hand 
and I prayed for him and he held my hand   so tight.
	"I knew he could hear every word so I told him 
that he was going to be very happy and I said, 'God is 
going to be with you and he is with you right now.' 
He blinked his eyes again and five minutes later he 
passed away."
	Ziffer said not all patients die alone and afraid. 
Sometimes, a patient is lucky enough to recover.
	"It doesn't happen very often,"she said. "In all 
the years I have been doing this it has only 
happened once to me. We never expected it but it 
was so magnificent to see him rally and come back. I 
still keep in touch with him."
	Finklestein is another patient who is seemingly 
beating the odds. While most patients survive less 
than six months after being admitted to hospice, 
Finklestein is still going strong after nearly 18 
months.
	"I was living in my apartment and I was sitting 
outdoors on a chair,"Finklestein said. "All of a sudden 
things were going black. I tried to reach for 
something and I fell on the ground. My doctor came 
to see me and told me I was (being admitted) to 
hospice.
	"That's where they (take) people when they 
think they're going to die. But I didn't die. I fooled 
them all."
	Since then, Wieczorek and Finklestein have 
been enjoying their time together, looking forward to 
each week and to memories.
	"Yes, I fooled them all,"Finklestein said again to 
Wieczorek with a smile.
	"Yep, you were ornery enough to stay 
alive,"Wieczorek said back, hugging her tightly.
	"Don't use that language."
	"Sorry,"Wieczorek said, with a sheepish grin. "I 
mean you were nice enough to stay around."
	As the two broke up into a fit of laughter once 
again, Finklestein turned to Wieczorek and smiled.
	"She's like a daughter to me,"she said. "I don't 
know what I would do without her."

Return to Contents List

Courting jurors summons plenty of weird excuses

(Click here for full photo and caption.)
* By Laura Anderson *
	
	Maricopa County Assistant Jury Commissioner 
Helen Caufman couldn't believe it when she opened a 
letter from former savings and loan head Charles 
Keating Jr.
	Keating, who had been summoned to serve jury 
duty in Maricopa County Superior Court, had legal 
problems of his own.
	Caufman conceded that Keating provided one of 
the best excuses she had ever encountered in her job 
as the chief listener of why people cannot serve. He 
could not appear because he was enmeshed in a 
high-profile case defending himself in a California 
state court against charges that he had defrauded 
investors in his Lincoln Savings and Loan Association.
	"It was weird,"Caufman said.
	She excused him.
	As an assistant jury commissioner for Arizona's 
busiest court, Caufman listens to thousands of 
excuses a year. Of the 450,000 registered voters in 
the county who are summoned to serve their legal 
duty, nearly 100,000 have excuses for why they 
can't make it, she said.
	The O.J. Simpson case thrust the jury selection 
process into the national spotlight when Los Angeles 
Superior Court Judge Lance A. Ito ordered 1,000 
prospects summoned and questioned in hopes of 
finding 12 jurors and eight alternates for that 
sensational murder trial. 
	And Lubbock, Texas, made national news 
earlier this year when only 238 of 725 prospective 
jurors responded to summonses, causing the sheriff 
to consider issuing contempt of court warrants and 
possibly arresting residents who had disregarded 
calls for jury duty. 

Designed to Protect Rights
	David Bodney, media law attorney and a 
partner in the law firm of Steptoe & Johnson in 
Phoenix, said the American jury system is designed 
to protect the due process rights of the accused.
	"It originated when individuals in society were 
more directly involved in the affairs of the 
community,"Bodney said. "The jury system is based 
on the notion that fairness in criminal proceedings 
can be ensured when the fate of the accused is in the 
hands of his peers."
	However, Bodney added that most members of 
contemporary society are "disconnected"from their 
community and often are not interested in 
performing their civic responsibilities.	
	Caufman has had many encounters with people 
trying to avoid their civic responsibility of serving.
	"Once I had a juror leave a note on the counter 
that said 'I do not have all day to wait around,'"she 
said. '"My time is valuable. I have a 3:15 
appointment in north Phoenix; leaving at 1:30, send 
the sheriff if you need me.'"
	Prompted by the jury selection process for the 
Simpson trial, the Los Angeles Times conducted a 
public opinion poll in connection with a four-part 
series that examined the strengths and weaknesses 
of the nation's jury system. The newspaper 
questioned 1,703 Los Angeles County adults. 
	The survey asked respondents if they had 
confidence in the jury system. Thirty-nine percent 
said they had a great deal or quite a lot of 
confidence; 55 percent said they had only some or 
very little confidence; and 6 percent said they didn't 
know.
	The survey asked people if they thought jury 
duty was a civic responsibility or a personal choice. 
Forty-one percent said it was a civic responsibility; 
57 percent said it was a personal choice; and 2 
percent said they didn't know.
	The poll also asked if people were inclined to 
serve or not to serve on a jury. Fifty-four percent 
said they were inclined to serve; 44 percent said 
they were not inclined to serve; and 2 percent said 
they didn't know.
	Bodney said he thinks the jury system basically 
is effective, but high-profile cases can create 
problems. The attempts by the courts to find an 
"untainted"jury is unwise, he added.
	"In high-profile cases, finding an untainted jury 
often does so at the cost of juror intellect and 
awareness,"he said. "They should look for more well-
informed persons who are willing to strip themselves 
of their prejudices. Sometimes cases are not 
determined by a jury of peers, just idiots. This is not 
in society's interest."
	Caufman said that she has received some very 
"unusual"mail during the past few years. She said 
some jury questionnaires are returned with labels 
written on the envelope such as "Forwarding 
expired" or "Earth P.O. Box #, moved and left no 
forwarding."
	Caufman also recalled a letter from another 
person who claimed, "I can't show up at court early 
in the morning because I go out at night with Satan."

A Major Undertaking
	Caufman's office mails more than 7,000 
summons each week to obtain jurors for the 
Maricopa County Superior Courthouses in downtown 
Phoenix and Mesa, for county and state grand juries, 
and for 21 justice courts and six municipal courts. 
The mailing list of 450,000 potential jurors is drawn 
every six months. It originates from a master list of 
county residents who are registered voters or who 
are licensed drivers over age 18 .
	Those who are summoned for jury duty 
technically serve only the day they are called or for 
the length of the trial should they be selected, 
Caufman said.
	The system has been in place for 10 years.
	"In 1985 we switched to one trial or one day 
to reduce the burden on the juror served,"Caufman 
said.
	Under the previous system, potential jurors 
were called between 2 p.m. and 4 p.m. to come in for 
the following day. Jurors were on call for a fixed 
period of time.
	"You would never see a doctor come in 1980, 
but you'll see them come in today,"Caufman said. 
"And they'll do their day. And attorneys will do it. 
You get a lot more professional people."		
	Each summons is accompanied by a 
questionnaire to determine a potential juror's 
qualifications to serve. Each person who seeks to 
be excused must explain why he or she is not eligible
 for service.
	The Office of the Jury Commissioner routinely 
grants excuses to people who provide a doctor's 
statement that explains a continuing, debilitating 
physical or mental illness. It also excuses people who 
are undergoing extreme financial hardship, have no 
transportation, must care for children or relatives, 
have served as a juror within the past 18 months or 
currently are in the military service. 
	Potential jurors who seek to be excused for 
other reasons are dealt with on a case-by-case basis.
	Caufman said her office sometimes receives 
letters from potential jurors who are graphic in their 
language.
	"Once in a while someone writes a letter that is 
so vulgar and obnoxious,"Caufman added. "A few 
years ago, if you wrote a letter like that it was a 
violation of pornography laws. It isn't anymore; it's 
just an expression of free speech.
	"So when we get a letter that is really bad, we 
just send the person a letter that says 'you did not 
qualify for jury excuse, and you therefore are to 
appear.' It is not uncommon to send the letter to the 
judge so he has an opportunity to read the 
correspondence."
	A juror who fails to attend court when 
summoned can be cited for direct contempt of court 
and may be forced to attend. The juror also may 
receive a fine not to exceed $100.
	Each juror is paid $12 per day in court by the 
county.  The county also pays 25.5 cents per mile 
traveled from the juror's residence to the court and 
back.
	An employer cannot, by law, penalize an 
employee for missing work because of jury duty. 
However, an employer is not required to compensate 
an employee who misses work. 
	Some people feel it is their civic responsibility 
to serve on jury duty and will serve even if their 
employer will not compensate them, Caufman said.
	"Once I had a young lady who was selected for 
a high-profile case who worked for a large 
company,"Caufman said. "The trial was expected to 
last six to eight weeks and they were not going to 
pay her while she served. 
	"Well, she found out they paid one of (their 
male employees) to go to a pro golf tournament as an 
amateur and they paid his expenses. So she battled 
the company to get paid to serve. You have to admire 
a 21-year-old going against big business."
	ASU's policy regarding faculty members and 
academic professionals who are called to jury duty is 
that the director or chair of the person's unit grants a 
leave of absence and the person is paid for the days' 
absent. However, the employee must sign over to the 
university his or her jury duty checkÐminus the 
travel stipend.
		
Dedicated Citizens
	Because Arizona has a large retirement 
population, the maximum age to serve was removed 
in 1972, Caufman said.
	"Federal court excuses you at 70 with no 
questions asked,"she added. "In our court, our rule of 
thumb is if you're physically able and want to do this 
we will let you serve."
	She said if people are more than 70 and have 
physical problems they are excused from serving.	
	"The oldest we've had was 92,"Caufman said. 
"She did ballroom dancing to keep herself active and 
she was just as spry and as pleasant as she could be.
	"I had a man come in and he got on a trial that 
was scheduled to go approximately four weeks and 
he didn't have four weeks. He literally did not have 
four weeks to live. 
	"He came back and told us this, but he did not 
tell the judge. He asked if the trial was going to be 
real lengthy and 
said he felt he could do things for a few days, but he 
didn't feel he could deal with that much.
	"He didn't really explain that to the judge, but 
he was excused anyway. He said he had some 
business to handle, and he did. He only lived another 
two or three weeks."
	She also recalled a man "who rode a bicycle and 
wanted to know if we had shower facilities because 
he had driven 42 miles to get to court."
	On another occasion, a woman from Sun City 
said she wasn't sure if she could get to the 
courthouse in Mesa but she was willing to give it a 
try. "She just wanted to know if there was a place 
that she could get her batteries recharged on her golf 
cart,"Caufman said.
	Once a man who had not asked to be excused 
reported for jury duty. "He took care of his 
father,"Caufman said. "He left his 84-year-old father 
alone in bed with an IV in his arm to come in."
	Caufman has other stories of dedication.
	"Sometimes people come in and all of a sudden 
they are reminded of what's going on,"she said. "They 
think they can do this and get here and I see tears 
streaming down their face, and I find out they have a 
daughter who is terminal and they thought they'd do 
their civic duty but when they get into the courtroom 
reality hits.
	"Sometimes you see parents who come in and 
do jury duty and their daughter was the victim of a 
very high-profile crime. But they come in and do 
their service and say 'we're just paying back.'"

Clever Ploys
	Not all people who are called for jury duty are 
dedicated and civic-minded.
	Caufman said one person asked to be excused 
from jury duty because of pressing matters at his 
house. The reason: "My dog is diabetic and I can't 
leave it home alone."
	Some potential jurors have interesting motives.
	"We had one lady who wanted to know if we 
still sequester jurors, and if she gets sequestered 
could we please put her in a room with a nice-
looking young man,"Caufman said.
	She recalled another incident that made her 
smile: "Once, when his wife was being led to the 
courtroom to be questioned, a man said, 'You don't 
really want my wife; she spent 17 years in a mental 
institution.'"
	Caufman's office deals with all kinds of people, 
some interesting, some aggravating.
	One thing is clear, however: a well-oiled 
machine is necessary to make the system work.	
	The process of selecting a jury is called "voir 
dire."During this stage, the judge or lawyers ask 
potential jurors questions about themselves and their 
prejudices.
	A juror likely will be disqualified "for 
cause,"such as he is closely related to one of the 
parties in the case; he has a business relationship 
with one of the lawyers or parties; or he has some 
personal knowledge of the case. 
	Lawyers can remove a certain number of jurors 
through peremptory challengesÐthe mechanism 
through which lawyers basically "try to get rid of 
people who are most likely to rule against their 
client,"attorney Bodney said. 
	During the fourth quarter of 1994, 12,122 
jurors reported to courts in Maricopa County. The 
courts sent 11,345 people to voir dire, 94 percent of 
those who reported for jury duty. Twenty-five 
percent of those who were called in for voir dire 
were challenged for cause; 25.2 percent were 
dismissed via peremptory challenges; 23.7 percent 
were sworn in for a trial panel; and 26.2 percent 
were not used.
	Eventually, 2,669 jurors were sworn in and 
were able to sit in judgment at a trial, according to 
figures supplied by Maricopa County Superior Court.
	The Office of the Jury Commissioner strives to 
send at least 85 percent of the potential jurors to 
voir dire, Caufman said. In some cities, courts will 
make jurors wait all day even when there aren't 
enough cases to be heard, she added.
	"We don't make the jurors sit around,"she said.
	The demographics of the jurors summoned for 
duty during the fourth quarter roughly mirrored 
Maricopa County's population. For example, of those 
summoned, 85.5 percent were white (compared to 
the county's 80.7 percent). Other breakdowns of 
those summoned (with actual county figures in 
parentheses): Hispanic, 9.3 percent (13.4 percent); 
Black, 2.5 percent (3 percent); Native American, .9 
percent (1.2 percent); Asian, .8 percent (1.6 percent); 
and other, 1 percent (.1 percent).
	Also, 53.3 percent of those summoned were 
males compared to the county's 48.6 percent; 46.7 
percent were females compared to the county's 51.4 
percent.
	Approximately 100,300 summons were mailed 
for jury service in all Maricopa County courts for the 
fourth quarter of 1994, according to figures supplied 
by the Office of the Jury Commissioner. 
	Of those responding, 6,989 were found to be 
unqualified for service, including  people who were 
not citizens, were not residents, were not able to 
speak English, were convicted felons or were under 
18. An additional 22,352 were excused for legitimate 
reasons. More than 23 percent of the total summons 
mailed were returned from the post office identified 
as undeliverable. 

A Numbers Game
	For Maricopa County's registered voters and 
licensed drivers over 18, receiving a summons for 
jury duty is a statistical likelihood. It's just a matter 
of time.
	"It's kind of an inconvenience,"said Kelly 
Metteer, a clerical worker who was called to Superior 
Court this spring. "However, I've managed to skim by 
(by not having to serve) it for a number of years."
	Maurice Schelstraete, a retired Phoenix 
resident who was on call every Tuesday and 
Thursday for four months on a county grand jury, 
said serving is an obligation that every citizen should 
fulfill. However, it inconvenienced him this spring. A 
devoted baseball fan, he wasn't able to go to spring 
training games because of his jury duty schedule. 
	"If you want to keep law and order, then you 
should do your service,"said John Venator, a self-
employed salesman who also was called to Superior 
Court. 
	Cecelia Richards, a housewife, said she was 
hoping to get on a jury, but wasn't sure if she could. 
 	"I'm a little anxious because of my health 
problems," Richards said. "I thought about calling in 
to get excused, but I'll just see what happens."
	Sandy Miller, an ASU senior finance major, said 
she was summoned for jury duty last June.
	"After I waited in the assembly room for about 
three hours, I got called in to be questioned about a 
case,"Miller said. "It was about a girl who allegedly 
had robbed a liquor store or something, killed the 
owner and was drinking even though she was not 21. 
	"I totally wanted to be on the jury, but when 
they asked if I had any time conflicts with the trial, I 
told them I had summer school, so I was dismissed."
	Superior Court Judge Maurice Portley said the 
jury system works well for one main reason: "People 
will allow other citizens to listen to facts and make 
decisions about who's guilty and who should pay.
	"The jury is the bulwark between having a 
police state and vigilante justice. If there were no 
jury, people would take justice into their own hands.
	"Juries decide cases, judges don't."

Return to Contents List

Front yard or junk yard?

Tempe's 'nuisance patrol' steps in when neighbors complain

(Click here for full photo and caption.)
* By Todd Kelly *

	There's a couch on the neighbor's roof.
	The guy down the street has five undrivable 
cars on his property.
	The woman across the street has weeds 4 feet 
high along the curb.
	There's a man who's building a boat in his back 
yard.
	When there's a problem like this, it's time for 
the nuisance inspectors to step in.
	To most people, it seems, the inspectors are 
saviors of order, ensuring peace and safety. To 
others, the ones who want to do whatever they want 
with their property, regardless of what others think, 
the inspectors are the jerks who come around and 
tell people what to do.
	Tempe has a group of five inspectors who 
patrol the neighborhoods, responding to complaints 
of citizens. The inspectors are the city's method to 
maintain beauty and order in the neighborhoods.
	Tempe is not the only city with a nuisance 
patrol, although other city's might use other terms 
for it. In Scottsdale, it's Code Enforcement. In 
Phoenix, it's the Neighborhood Maintenance and 
Zoning Enforcement Division. In Mesa, it's the Zoning 
Enforcement and Nuisance Abatement, in the city's 
building inspection division.
	In Tempe, the inspectors' main duty is to 
enforce the nuisance ordinance and the neighborhood 
enhancement rules. They're not cops - they work in 
the city's building safety department. One of them is 
Mike Speranza, whose business card reads code 
enforcement manager. He's got four inspectors 
working with him: Walt Douglas, Dave Christ, Keith 
Archibald and Brian Augustine.
	Their most common problem is cars and car 
parts lying around yards and houses. People like to 
save parts - tires, wheels, engines, rims, anything 
that may be used again.
	There's a story of a couple who drove down 
from Colorado and the husband parked the car in the 
driveway when they got to their house. That's the 
last time he drove the car, and that was nine years 
ago. Speranza said when his inspectors showed up, 
they were welcomed.
	"His wife was so happy," he said. "She said, 'Give 
me that notice. I've been asking him to get rid of that 
car. We drove down, parked that car and it hasn't 
moved in nine years.' You could tell she was happy to 
get rid of it. Sometimes people have to be spurred on 
to get rid of their junk.
	"Some people get upset when you tell them to 
clean the property. Other people say 'You're right. 
I've been meaning to do it.'"
	He also said it's nice when people are around to 
acknowledge the work he and his inspectors do. But 
the inspectors keep plugging away at it, patrolling 
the city for any sign of danger or ugliness.
	"I don't dwell on it, but it is a negative job,"said 
Speranza, who's worked for the city for 15 years. 
"You've got somebody unhappy calling you, and 
they're unhappy because they don't like the way 
someone else's property looks, and then when you go 
to that other person's property, he doesn't like the 
idea of you coming along and telling him what to do 
on his property. So you got two negatives going on."
	Despite the difficulties, Speranza and his task 
force generally obtain compliance from residents. It's 
assumed that the city is better off because of it.	
	Not everything out of the ordinary is illegal, 
dangerous or both, Speranza said. A lot of what he 
and his inspectors do pertains to maintaining a sense 
of order and aesthetics in a neighborhood.

It's the city's business
	Whether or not people like it or understand it, 
it's the city's business what people do with a house. 
It also becomes everybody else's business, too. If 
there's a violation of a city code, the inspectors will 
enforce it. They'll come to a house and tell the 
occupants that they have 20 days to clean up 
whatever it is that needs to be cleaned up.
	Sometimes, however, 20 days simply isn't 
enough time, as inspector Douglas can attest. There's 
a house on Orange Street that remains dirty.
	"I initially got that complaint on 2-6 of '95,"he 
said, adding that this is an unusual length of time to 
clean up a property.
	The reason this one has taken so long is that 
the owner of the house, a woman in her 80s, was 
moved to a nursing home after a heart attack. 
Douglas said her son doubted she would be coming 
out of the rest home, and the son wasn't in financial 
position to take care of the property. The city then 
basically took charge and moved to clean up the 
mess.
	"He's got his life to lead, and that house down 
there just, after a while, turned into an 
afterthought, "Douglas said. "He tried to stay in the 
house for awhile."
	In most cases, though, the city can contact a 
property owner and can move much quicker in 
working out a solution to a messy residence.
	Every once in a while, if the inspectors can't 
enforce an ordinance, the fire department might be 
called in. That usually happens about 10 or 12 times 
a year, according to Russ Wollam, public information 
officer for the Tempe Fire Department.
	Section 21-3 of the Tempe Code for public 
nuisances lists the violations:
	They include anything that:
	The public nuisance ordinance works on a 
complaint basis. It  requires neighbors to call the city 
and complain. In Tempe, the people don't need to 
identify themselves to the inspectors, Speranza said.
	"We will accept anonymous complaints,"he said, 
which they occur about 40 percent of the time.
	In Mesa, where inspectors also respond to 
complaints in a similar manner, Paul Medlock of the 
Mesa Building Inspections Department said 
anonymous calls are accepted, but it helps to leave 
your name with the inspector.	
	"If we go out on a complaint and we don't have 
enough information and we can't get back to the 
complainant, then we basically have to wait until 
they call back for an update,"he said. Medlock also 
said that most people "by far"choose to not identify 
themselves to the inspectors.
	The inspectors keep a record of each call that 
comes in, each time they visit a neighborhood, each 
time they notify someone of a violation. Everything is 
written down on forms and everything that gets 
written down becomes public record, which means 
that when someone files a complaint, his neighbor 
can easily figure out if it were him.
	"And people want to remain anonymous so 
their neighbor doesn't come over and harass them or 
whatever,"Medlock said. "But we cannot hide any 
body's name legally."
	Tempe has the same rules to follow about 
public disclosure of documents, and Speranza said 
that a lot of people simply choose to remain 
anonymous when calling his department.
	
Riding along with an inspector
	Speranza likes to explain his business as he 
drives around the city and points out all of the 
infractions.
	"We had a guy on 13th Street that was digging 
a basement in his front yard. The thing was 7 feet 
deep,"he said. "He was a character. He used to paint 
his trees red and white and he had signs all over his 
house.
	"The trees were red and white so they'd look 
like barber poles, and he'd have dummies up on the 
roof, looking over the roof, and he'd have all kinds of 
signs up there. He was sort of funny."
	Speranza added that the man had fought in a 
war and "he didn't come back all in one piece. But 
he'd do all these things and one of them was he 
decided to make a basement."
	The ordinance describes this as an example of 
"any unguarded or abandoned excavation, pit, well or 
hole dangerous to life."If the man had a fence 
surrounding his would-be basement, so that no 
unsuspecting passer-by could fall in, it would have 
been OK.
	In another case, Speranza said his problem 
with a woman started with high weeds, parked cars 
on the lawn and what amounted to a truckload or 
two of stuff in the driveway.
	"See all that green stuff?"Speranza asked, 
pointing to the woman's driveway. "That green tarp? 
She's got nothing but junk under there. Just things: 
boxes, metal, cans. Just junk. She's covered it since 
we cited her, but we still want it removed. It's gotta' 
go.
	"She's got all kinds of stuff under there and 
that's what got the neighbors complaining about it. 
She's got this car there. I didn't check the registration 
but it's probably from year one."
	The tags say 1983. The car looks like it hasn't 
been driven since.
	To the people who live in the area, the yard is 
unsightly, but it's also a potential fire hazard. 	
	It's Wollam's job to know all about fire risks.
	"You have two hazards,"he said. "One is once a 
fire does occur, it makes it even more difficult for the 
fire department to gain access to the structure to 
effect search and rescue and to gain fire 
extinguishment.
	"But it also contributes to the fire spread. Once 
you have a fire occurring in the house, it becomes 
involved in the property. Then it can extend to 
adjoining buildings and property."
	Speranza said that some of the people who 
allow things to gather on their property "dance to a 
different drummer. That's my terminology for the 
one's that are a little wacky. It's either that or 
they're people who do not want to conform. They 
think it's their property, they should be able to do 
whatever they want that has no impact on their 
neighbors, but it does have an impact."
	
From cars to anything else
	It seems like Speranza could talk for hours 
about the things he's seen.
	"I'll show you a house,"he said. "If you want to 
live next to a garage, you move next to this guy."
	About 15 minutes later, Speranza decided to 
check on an empty lot on South Stanley Place. The lot 
is now remarkably clean, to his surprise.
	"We had a complaint here of junk cars,"and 
people have been dumping trash on the property, he 
said.
	"This is where it was,"he added, pointing to the 
lot. "There were two junk cars, there were couches, 
tables, old furniture. And it's gone."
	He's not the only one glad to see the mess 
cleaned up. A neighbor, who happened to be driving 
off as Speranza showed up after seeing the City of 
Tempe logo on the side of the car.
	"Thank you,"he said.
	"What happened to my stuff here?"he asked 
the man.
	"The owner came by and towed it all off."
	"Alright."
	The man thanked him again, and Speranza told 
him to call again, if necessary.
	Speranza said that it's rare to run into someone 
who thanks him or the other inspectors. 
Unfortunately, that's just the nature of the job.
	Their involvement around town is a response 
to the nature of people and how they choose to live. 
Nuisances and those neighbors that allow them are in 
most neighborhoods. It's safe to say that everybody 
knows someone who's a either a slob or a packrat.
	"In a lot of lower socioeconomic neighborhoods, 
people use couches and kitchen tables as a gathering 
place to sit (in front of the house),"Speranza said. 
"And we realize that not everybody's got plastic patio 
furniture that they can sit on.
	"Let's say you don't have a lot of money and 
you get a tire that may have some use. Instead of 
throwing it away, you save it - you may need it 
someday.
	"Sometimes, they do it for effect. We used to 
have (some ASU) students on the corner of 13th 
Street and Hardy Drive. They were renting and on 
their roof they had a couch and two chairs. The 
neighbors would call up on them all the time. 'You 
gotta' do something! They got a couch on the roof!' 
Well, nothing in the ordinance says you can't have a 
couch on the roof. There was really no violation. But 
they did it. They did it for attention.
	A lot of people keep stuff "in the hope that 
they're going to use it, and a lot keep it because they 
cannot part with it. It's almost like a 
disease,"Speranza said.
    "Many years ago we had a professor at ASU and 
(he had) this house. It was vacant but he owned it, 
and the entire inside of the house was full of things: 
magazines, typewriters, you name it. On the outside, 
the whole back yard was full of things, just things he 
had picked up. You couldn't walk in the back yard. 
I'll never forget it."
    Speranza said the man was told to get rid of the 
stuff. It was becoming a nuisance. He added that the 
man told him: "'I know, I know I do. You don't 
understand. I know where everything here came 
from. It's hard to part with it. It's really hard. You 
just don't understand.'"
	
The process of abatement
	The city likes to give people ample time to 
clean up their property. The first notice will be 
delivered in person or sent by certified mail. If the 
owner cannot be located, notice of abatement will be 
posted on the building and printed in the newspaper 
at least two times. The owner then has 20 days to 
take care of it or the inspectors can request funds to 
have it cleaned. The owner is charged for the cost of 
the cleanup. 
	The city will then hold a lien on the property 
until the owner pays. Commercial properties can 
become problem areas, too, although they're not a 
problem as often. Speranza described one such 
property north of the Salt River.
	"It's a business,"he said. "We cited him. He said, 
'Do what you're going to do.'''
	The property is about one block wide by two 
blocks deep. Speranza said that the bid to clean it 
was in the $5,000 range because front loaders, 
trucks, dumping fees, labor and insurance on the 
labor were needed to get it cleaned.
	For the most part, he said people are becoming 
more aware of the fact that Tempe has a city code 
and rules they must follow.
	"I think that most people (homeowners) are 
aware,"he said.
	At the end of the ride-around, near the end of 
another day patrolling the city, Speranza rounded 
another corner at another intersection in Tempe. As 
his eyes scanned the area, he said, "That's what we 
do. 
	"Lots of laughs."

Return to Contents List

ASU's international students drawn to science, technology

(Click here for full photo and caption.)
* By Garin Groff *

	In China, most parents don't want their 
children to study politics or law when they go to 
college.
	They push science or technology.
	"That makes life easier,"said Weiguo Xie, a 38-
year-old Chinese student pursuing a doctoral degree 
in electrical engineering at ASU. "Some may still have 
fears about going into politics due to the past 
experiences."
	Parents prefer that their children don't have a 
liberal arts education, fearing the young may be 
inspired to write or speak out against the 
government - actions that could get them thrown in 
jail, Xie said.
	With the recent, dramatic changes in China's 
booming economy and turbulent political landscape, 
Xie said the most important thing for Chinese 
students to learn is marketable technical skills. Such 
knowledge will ensure a stable job regardless of 
what changes take place in China, he said.
	Xie, a Chinese citizen who came to ASU 2 1/2 
years ago after obtaining his master's degree in 
China, is not alone is his desire to obtain a 
marketable skill by studying in the United States.
	Of the 2,312 international students at ASU, 40.9 
percent of them, or 946 students, are enrolled in the 
College of Engineering and Applied Sciences. This is 
by far - in numbers and percentages - the most 
popular college at ASU for international students.

Checking the student census
	International student statistics for this article 
were compiled by using the fall 1994 student census 
database and seperating students with 900-prefixes 
in their student identification numbers from the rest 
of the student population. International students are 
assigned 900-prefixes for their student numbers.
	 India is the top nation of origin for foreign 
students, with 319 students studying here. Second is 
China, with 251 students, followed by Taiwan, with 
205 students. Together, these three nations supply 
33.6 percent of the university's international 
students.
	Of the engineering college's 6,592 graduate and 
undergraduate students, 15.1 percent are 
international students. By comparison, only 5.4 
percent of ASU's 42,813 students are international 
students.
	The interim dean of the College of Engineering 
and Applied Sciences attributes the high percentage 
of international students in his college to a greater 
appreciation of technology education in other 
countries.
	"Domestic students are more apt to get a job 
and get about their lives,"said interim dean Dan 
Jankowski.
	He said the college is trying to get more 
domestic students interested in engineering by 
increasing recruiting efforts. However, Jankowski 
said American students often have a negative view 
of technological fields like engineering because of 
recent layoffs in that field and because the skills are 
difficult to learn.
	The college with the second largest number of 
international students is the College of Liberal Arts 
and Science. It has 506 international students in it.
	Although the college is the largest at the 
university, with 12,053 students, the percentage of 
international students enrolled there - 3.6 percent - 
is below the university average.
	Students from many other countries tend to be 
drawn to scientific and technical skills training at 
American universities because of their cultures, said 
liberal arts dean Gary Krahenbul.
	"Liberal arts education isn't available at all in 
China or in other countries,"he said. "That's very 
much a part of the Western tradition."
	International students are drawn to science 
and technology educations because of the tie 
between training and jobs, he said.
	"I think they're very career-minded,"Krahenbul 
said.
	The College of Architecture and Environmental 
Design has 103 international students, giving it the 
second-highest percentage of international students 
within an ASU college - 7.2 percent. However, it is 
sixth-largest college in terms of international 
students enrolled.

A competitive advantage
	John Meunier, dean of architecture and 
environmental design, said students from other 
countries want American education in the sciences 
because it gives them a competitive advantage in the 
marketplace.
	"There is a wide feeling in the developing 
world ... that America is the place to be if you want 
to be on the leading edge of technologies,"Meunier 
said.
	That was not always the case, Meunier said. 
Until the collapse of eastern European countries, the 
Soviet Union offered strong scientific education and 
social support systems. With the funding for such 
programs gone, America is the top choice for 
students studying abroad, Meunier said.
	However, he said the number of students 
studying here could drop as the gap between the 
strength of the dollar and some other world currency 
widens.
	Meunier said the overrepresentation of 
international students in some programs at ASU 
indicates how American culture values business over 
technology. He added that he is troubled so few 
American students are enrolled in advanced 
technological programs.
	"Society will prosper from its knowledge base, 
not its managerial skill base,"he said.
	The third-most popular college for 
international students, both in numbers enrolled and 
in percentage of the college's population, is the 
College of Business. About 5.3 percent of those in the 
college are international students.
	Dean Larry Penley attributed the popularity in 
part to a few programs in his college that have 
prestigious reputations, such as accounting, 
purchasing, logistics and marketing.
	He added that the general reputation of 
American business education and a general absence 
of business education elsewhere also draw foreign 
students here.
	Lloyd Brimhall, program coordinator of ASU's 
International Students Program, said students come 
to American universities because of good programs 
here and institutions in other countries often can't 
meet the demand for education.
	"They have quality institutions, but the 
institutions don't have the space for all the students 
who apply. There's more access to American 
education,"Brimhall said, adding that this is 
especially true in the case of engineering.
	ASU does not actively recruit students from 
other countries, Brimhall and several college deans 
said. Instead, it relies on word of mouth and sending 
information to students who express an interest in 
studying here.
	Xie said Chinese students want to study in 
America because people believe the United States 
has the most advances in science and technology.
	"Everybody who gets a degree here will get 
respect from the whole society,"he said.
	Undergraduate education in China is 
comparable to that in America, but China has few 
experimental facilities for the high-tech research 
necessary to teach students earning master's or 
Ph.D. degrees, Xie added.
	Fukwun Wang, a 30-year-old Taiwanese 
student pursuing a Ph.D. in industrial engineering, 
said these same reasons attract students from 
Taiwan to American universities. However, he said 
education in Taiwan is changing considerably as the 
nation becomes more developed.
	In the last five years or so, Taiwan has opened 
high-quality institutions where people can earn 
doctorates in science and engineering, said Wang, 
who has received his master's in statistics from ASU 
since he came here in 1989.
	Brimhall said he has noticed the makeup of 
international students change recently in one 
particular area - gender.
	Today, 65 percent of international students, or 
1,503 people, are males. He said this number was 
about 75 percent a few years ago.
	"Still, males are expected - more so than in our 
own culture - to be the ones to be educated,"Brimhall 
said.
	Jankowski said the engineering college is trying 
to attract more females by going to middle and high 
schools to show women they can be as successful as 
males.
	International students typically come from the 
middle- and upper-classes because studying abroad 
is so expensive. To study at ASU, foreign students 
pay out-of-state tuition, which recently rose 7.5 
percent, to $8,278 a year. However, international 
students can get waivers, Brimhall said.

Families have to pay 
	Most international students don't receive 
funding from their governments to study abroad, 
leaving families with the burden of paying for 
college, Brimhall said. Also, the U.S. government is 
not authorized to federally fund foreign students 
through loans or grants, he said.
	Another difficult financial factor facing 
international students is that they cannot work off 
campus because of immigration regulations. This is 
one reason why non-American students working on 
campus seem to be overrepresented, Brimhall said.	
	Both Xie and Wang said they plan to return to 
their native lands when they graduate. However, Xie 
said he has noticed that female students from China 
are less likely than males to want to return.
	Females like the living conditions in America 
better, whereas males are more likely to aspire to 
establishing a business or working at a high-level 
government position, he said.
	Xie, who expects to graduate in one year, said 
that even though he likes America, he wants to 
return to China because he can work better there 
without the language and cultural differences.
	Wang said he also likes America but wants to 
go back when he earns his Ph.D. degree in 1996.
	Jankowski said international students with 
degrees in the sciences have employment skills that 
are in high demand in America or in their 
homelands, especially in light of the computer 
revolution and other recent advances in technology.
	He attributed these advances as part of the 
reason why electrical engineering is the most popular 
major for international students, with 278 students, 
or 12 percent of all international students at ASU. Of 
the majors with 50 or more international students in 
them, five are in engineering fields - electrical, 
chemical, mechanical, industrial and civil. Two other 
science fields, mathematics and computer science, 
have more than 50 students each, resulting in seven 
of the top 11 majors as being related to science or 
technology.
	Regardless of the field international students 
study in the engineering college, Jankowski said they 
will have many opportunities.
	"If they learn well here, they can take a lot 
back with them," he said. "It seems to me like they 
would be very valued in their countries,"

Return to Contents List

This edition of The Electronic Bulldog

	Four in-depth articles written by ASU 
journalism students are featured in today's edition of 
The Bulldog, which is published periodically by 
the Cronkite School of Journalism and 
Telecommunication and ASU's Student Publications.
	The Bulldog is an outlet for journalism 
students who always are looking for places to 
publish. The articles will range from feature stories 
to hard-hitting investigative articles. After all, we are 
The Bulldog.	
	Today's newspaper was produced electronically 
by journalism students. Special thanks go to designer 
Jodi Goldblatt, photographer Jim Poulin and Vicki 
Carroll, who created The Electronic Bulldog. 
	We hope you enjoy The Bulldog. Look for 
us again in the fall.

Return to Contents List
Return to Electronic Bulldog Home Page