|

by Jessica McCann
The metaphor of
the "wall" between church and state has been, in a sense,
a mantra by which Americans have lived for generations.
"It is sort
of the fundamental creed that we all espouse, the notion of religion
as a private phenomenon," said Linell Cady, a professor of religious
studies at ASU. "We say it so frequently and unthinkingly that
in many respects we imagine the entire world is structured in the same
fashion, which, of course, it is not."
For many cultures,
religion is a social experience that impacts all aspects of life. Strong
religious identities and differences create the potential for -- perhaps
even likelihood of -- inherent disagreements and violent conflict.
To enhance research
and education of this social phenomenon, ASU has established a new Center
for the Study of Religion and Conflict. Among the first of its kind
in the nation, the center will explore the complex roles of religion
in contemporary conflicts and examine the fundamental issues driving
public debates.
"Religious-based
conflict exists in areas as diverse as foreign policy, international
law, teaching and learning in our schools, science and technology research
and application, news coverage and political ideology," said ASU
President Michael Crow, illustrating the potential breadth of the center's
work.
Plans for the center
began in late 2002, Cady was soon named as director, and several programs
and initiatives are already under way this year. Faculty seminars, undergraduate
research support, graduate fellowships, curriculum development, community
forums and visiting professorships are a few of the programs that are
expected to unfold in the next three years.
The role of religion
in conflict has become especially prominent with recent world events.
Violent clashes in the Middle East, India and Africa, as well as the
terrorist attacks in the United States, have made us all painfully aware
of the many serious conflicts between religions, as well as between
religions and the secular state.
"One thing
that certainly ought to be clear to everybody now is that religion is
not an unambiguously good thing," said Jeff Murphy, Regents Professor
of Law and Philosophy and affiliated faculty member in religious studies.
"Religion sometimes produces absolutely wonderful and blessed results,
but it sometimes also leads to some of the craziest and most dangerous
conflict of which human beings are capable."
With the growing
recognition of religion's enormous role in shaping public affairs around
the world, the creation of the center is particularly relevant. It will
bring together scholars from around the world and across the university
in an interdisciplinary scholarly enterprise. While religious studies
faculty will obviously play a key role, faculty from other academic
areas such as education, philosophy, law, social science and communication
will also contribute.
"Centers are
designed to create cross-departmental and cross-college connections
within the university, to bring together faculty expertise in various
areas," said Cady. "There are faculty working on issues of
religion across the university. If we can create the infrastructure
to bring them together in new ways, then collectively the yield of knowledge
will be much greater."
Enrollment in religion
classes is surging across the United States, according to college and
university officials. The trend is especially pronounced at ASU, which
has the largest enrollment in religious studies of any school in the
country.
The department
of religious studies at ASU was established in 1979, and it has grown
steadily through the years. Today, the university has approximately
4,400 students enrolled in more than 70 classes -- that's almost double
the number found at other schools with prominent religious departments
and a 50 percent increase in ASU's enrollment from just three years
ago. There are about 200 students majoring or minoring in religious
studies, and many students take the courses to fulfill general studies
requirements. In fact, one-third of all ASU students choose to take
a course in religious studies before they graduate.
The department
currently ranks 14th nationally among 450 such undergraduate programs,
according to the Gourman Report. The collective expertise of the 18
ranked faculty members is interdisciplinary, comprising doctorates in
history of religions, area studies, literature, anthropology, history
and theology. It spans the globe, and it covers numerous religious traditions,
including Judaism, Christianity, Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism and Native
American traditions.
Without the strong
foundation of faculty, curriculum and student interest in the religious
studies program at ASU, creation of the new center would not have been
possible. A seed grant from the ASU Office of Research and Economic
Affairs provided funding for the initiative. The objective is to get
the center's infrastructure and a few key programs off the ground during
the first year, and then leverage that success to help secure additional
funding outside the university through grants and private support.
By dedicating institutional
resources to the center, the university is demonstrating its support
of the programs being developed. Sociology Professor George Thomas pointed
out that institutional support increases the likelihood faculty will
obtain outside funding for research.
"Agencies
that fund research typically look for the support of the institution,"
Thomas said. "I can certainly submit a grant proposal on my own;
but this will provide a basis for my getting together with other scholars
on campus and submitting a joint proposal, under the auspices of the
center."
One of Thomas'
current research projects examines the historic and current conflicts
surrounding the teaching of religion in public schools -- a classic
example of the type of scholarship the center would encourage.
"So much of
the conflict and tension between particular religious groups and nation
states tends to center on what the public schools are going to teach
our children," Thomas explained. His latest project will document
how different countries have attempted to resolve this conflict. From
there Thomas will examine whether those solutions have been conducive
to peaceful resolution or have, in fact, generated additional conflict.
Thomas' project
reminds us that, while violent global clashes seem to dominate current
events, religious-based conflict is not necessarily always violent.
Stem cell research, evolution curriculum in public schools, human cloning
-- all have led to heated debate on religious grounds, but rarely to
violence, in the United States. "
Except for a few
examples, such as the assassination of abortionists, religious conflict
in America is a long way from becoming violent," Murphy said. "The
emotions may be violent and the passions may be high, but we have too
many checks-and-balances and Democratic institutions in place. Our whole
history goes against the idea that we could have anything resembling
religious warfare in America."
The influence
of religion in public life can also generate significant internal conflict,
as individuals struggle to determine religion's role in their own lives
and professions. That conflict can, in turn, impact public policy and
affairs.
In January 2003,
for example, the Vatican released a new set of guidelines approved by
Pope John Paul II for Catholic politicians in Europe and the United
States. It stated that church opposition to abortion and euthanasia
was not up for negotiation and instructed Catholic politicians to defend
"the basic right to life from conception to natural death."
Imagine the internal conflict a contemporary politician and devout Catholic
must reconcile to meet such a directive from the church.
Journalists, too,
face the challenge of addressing religion appropriately within their
profession, as struggles based on religious differences grip our nation
and the world more than ever before.
"One of the
acknowledged weaknesses of the media is its inability to cover religion
well, particularly domestically," said Joe Foote, director of the
Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication. "Reporting
seems to be most prevalent when conflict occurs. That distorts reality,
because religion certainly exists in normal times outside of conflict
in a much larger way than it does during conflict."
In the late 1990s,
ABC news anchor Peter Jennings became one of the first in the industry
to vigorously and openly criticize the lack of media coverage on religion.
He successfully lobbied his network to add a full-time religion reporter
to the staff. Last year, the Interfaith Alliance Foundation honored
Jennings for his coverage of the September 11 terrorist attacks, which
the organization said showed "great courage in addressing the difficult
issues related to religious diversity." Jennings' influence has
begun to make an impact in the industry in general.
"I think we're
seeing a period of renewed interest in religion and a greater willingness
to cover it," Foote said. "Peter Jennings, on the national
front, has been a major advocate of that."
When one begins
to consider religion and conflict from a multidisciplinary vantage,
it becomes clear just how broad and complex the issues can be. For example,
under what conditions could religion actually serve as the basis for
resolving conflict? Or, for that matter, how can one be entirely sure
that a particular conflict is genuinely religion-based?
"Just because
conflict is surrounded by the language of religion, doesn't mean that
the basis of that conflict is primarily religious," Murphy noted.
"A good example would be the conflict in Northern Ireland. There's
no doubt that's partly religious in foundation, and a lot of the talk
is Catholic versus Protestant, but a lot of the foundation of that conflict
is economic, as well."
Many world leaders
and economic analysts also have speculated that much of the current
turmoil in the Middle East is more the result of economic strife than
religious conflict. Such theories may be a subject of discussion at
the center's inaugural conference this April, which will focus on Islam
and the modern world. The keynote speaker will be Peter Bergen, a CNN
journalist and author of Holy War, Inc., a book about Osama bin Laden
and Islamic militant groups around the world.
"The conference
will explore various voices of Islam in the modern world, from the more
militant appropriation of the tradition to its more liberal currents,"
said Cady.
Much of the center's
early work will likely focus on current global conflicts, with the philosophy
that a better understanding of diverse religions is an important step
in resolving religious conflict. For example, Cady noted, Americans'
own model of church and state separation can hamper their understanding
of other societies around the world where religion plays a more public
role. That private model is essentially a Western export, and there
is some sentiment in other cultures that it is an imposition from the
West, a form of imperialism.
The fact that Muslim
extremists orchestrated the terrorist attacks on September 11 further
complicates the issue. As people struggle to understand, many are asking
the same questions.
"Do these
terrorist activities represent genuine Islam, or is this some kind of
lunatic fringe group?" Murphy posed. "For all I know, given
my own regrettable ignorance of Islam, these Islamic terrorists represent
their religion no better than the Branch Dividians represented Christianity.
That's certainly something this center could help us learn more about."
The current Muslim
worldwide population is estimated to be 1.3 billion people and a very
small fraction of those individuals are, in fact, terrorists. In an
address at the Nixon Center late last year, CIA Director George Tenet
pointed out that the Muslim world reaches from Morocco to Indonesia,
the largest Muslim country. The next three largest Muslim populations
are in Pakistan, Bangladesh and India. "Our foes are literally
'the fringe of the fringe' in the Muslim world -- the small subset of
radical Muslims who also happen to be violent and murderous," Tenet
said
"That is so
true," said Cady, "But it is also the case that there is some
dissatisfaction in a number of Muslim societies with the Western model
that positions religion as a minimalist factor in society and culture.
So that raises large questions about the relationship between societies
and what role religion should play."
And it is precisely
these types of large questions that ASU's Center for the Study of Religion
and Conflict will strive to someday answer.
Jessica McCann
is a professional freelance writer based in Scottsdale, Ariz.
|